About Us


David MacNiven - President

Dave has been working in the health insurance industry since 2015 and has assisted hundreds of Medicare beneficiaries, first as a captive agent working for an insurance company and then as an independent insurance agent with Nutmeg Advisory Group. Dave launched Nutmeg Insurance Advisors in 2021 to better serve the changing needs of his clients, their families and their businesses. He is currently serving as a member of the Board of Directors for the Hamden Regional Chamber of Commerce and as part of the membership committee for the Nutmeg State Networkers BNI.

Our Mission

Our mission is to provide our clients with assistance in understanding and making the right decisions when it comes to insurance. We have the skills, knowledge, and experience to help meet our client's established goals. Our personal goal is to become a lifetime resource for our clients and give them greater confidence in choosing their insurance plan.


People First: Our business is not transactional in nature; it is built on long-term relationships. We believe that success and balance begin with good health, so everything we do is in support of that for our families, our clients and our community.

Active Empathy: To better serve our clients and community, we dedicate ourselves to meeting people where they are in their lives without judgment and with a desire to help in the ways that we are able.

Never Stop Learning: We cultivate and practice a beginner’s mindset in all we do. We approach every interaction with an attitude of openness, eagerness and a lack of preconceptions. We simplify the complex world of health insurance, and we never stop learning.

Stronger Together: We make intentional decisions and actions to benefit others and help to make our communities strong. We work in service to our clients, to the communities we are a part of and to each other as we grow.

Do the Right Thing: Integrity is the foundation for everything we do. We take ownership of our actions and strive to always do the right thing.

Nutmeg Insurance Advisors

1 St. John St.
North Haven, CT 06473


  [email protected]